All categories
Business & Offices
Electronics & Media
Fashion & Accessories
Groceries & Essentials
Health & Personal Care
Home & Living
Kids & Family
Sports & Outdoors
Search in ZoneOffer
Eggnog feels like a warm holiday hug in a glass — rich, creamy, and a little bit nostalgic. Whether you grew up with a family recipe or you’re discovering it at the grocery aisle for the first time, store-bought eggnog makes entertaining simple and satisfying. It’s an easy way to bring festive flavor to gatherings without spending hours at the stove.
Not all eggnogs are created equal. Look at the label for richness (typically measured by milkfat or cream content), sweetness level, and whether it’s dairy, plant-based, or spiked with alcohol. For everyday sipping, a carton in a pint or quart range works well; for parties you might grab a half-gallon or gallon. And if you care about ingredients, check for real eggs versus egg yolk substitutes and whether the product is pasteurized.
Quality eggnog often lists whole milk, heavy cream, sugar, eggs, and natural spices like nutmeg and cinnamon near the top of the ingredient list. If you see long strings of unfamiliar additives, you might be sacrificing taste for a longer shelf life. Also, density matters: thicker eggnog is richer and feels more indulgent in a 6 to 8 fluid ounce serving.
Some stores consistently stock standout eggnogs—classic recipes, limited-edition seasonal twists, and spiked options. Below are five reliable picks available across major U.S. retailers, plus tips on which store typically offers the best deals or hardest-to-find varieties.
Whole Foods tends to carry artisanal and organic eggnogs from local creamery brands and their own 365 line. If you want something with higher cream content and clean labels, this is a great stop. Whole Foods also stocks plant-based alternatives made from almond or oat milk for a lighter yet still festive sip. Expect to find pints and quarts priced slightly higher than mass-market brands, but they’re often worth it when you want a premium texture and bold nutmeg notes.
Trader Joe’s gets cult status for seasonal items, and their eggnog is no exception. Their cartons typically deliver creamy richness at a wallet-friendly price, and you’ll sometimes find limited flavors like vanilla or caramel swirl. If you’re hosting on a budget but don’t want to skimp on taste, Trader Joe’s is a smart first stop. They usually sell eggnog in quart-sized cartons that pour thick and pair well with a splash of rum.
Walmart stock covers the full spectrum: national brands, private-label eggnog, lite versions, and often boxed spiked variations around the holidays. You’ll find pints, quarts, and half-gallons—ideal when you’re buying for a big group. Walmart frequently runs promotions during November and December, so check weekly ads if you’re planning a big purchase. Their national reach makes it a reliable choice for last-minute shoppers.
Kroger stores, including Fry’s and King Soopers where present, usually carry classic brand-name eggnogs alongside Kroger’s store-brand options. Look for Kroger weekly digital coupons or buy-one-get-one deals that can save you money on multiple cartons. Kroger’s variety means you can get traditional, reduced-fat, and ready-to-drink spiked varieties in one trip.
If you’re hosting a holiday party, Costco is excellent for buying eggnog in larger quantities—often in sizable multi-packs or large containers. You’ll get better per-ounce value here than buying single cartons everywhere. Costco also stocks some branded seasonal flavors and occasionally carries pre-mixed, spiked eggnog for shoppers who want convenience plus bulk savings.
If you’re hunting for something unique, independent dairies and specialty grocers often have limited-run eggnogs made with local dairy and traditional techniques. Look to regional markets, farmers’ markets, and specialty food shops for small-batch, old-fashioned recipes that taste closer to homemade. These options often shine in texture and flavor, offering a real difference for true aficionados.
Non-dairy eggnogs made from oat, almond, or coconut milk are increasingly available at stores like Whole Foods, Trader Joe’s, and Target. These versions mimic the creaminess using plant-based thickeners and often include the same festive spices. While they aren’t identical to dairy eggnog in mouthfeel, they offer a pleasing alternative for those avoiding dairy and still work great for mixed drinks and desserts.
Non-alcoholic eggnog is a must for family-friendly gatherings and keeps kids included in holiday toasts. But if you want an adult-only party, spiked eggnog introduces warming alcohol notes—rum and brandy being the classics. Many stores offer pre-spiked bottles, while others sell cocktail-ready eggnog that you can spike at home to taste.
Rum pairs naturally with the sweet, custardy profile of eggnog, while brandy adds depth and complexity. Bourbon brings caramel and vanilla notes that play nicely with nutmeg. A general guideline is 1 to 1.5 fluid ounces of spirit per 6 to 8 fluid ounce serving, but always taste as you go—people’s tolerance and preference vary.
Planning quantity can save you from embarrassing shortages. For a mixed-age crowd at a 3-hour gathering, plan on about 6 to 8 fluid ounces per adult if you’re serving other drinks, and 4 to 6 fluid ounces per kid or non-drinker. That means a dozen adults drinking eggnog would need roughly 6 to 9 pints total, or about 1.5 to 2 gallons. If eggnog is your primary beverage, scale up to 8 to 12 fluid ounces per adult.
One quart equals 32 fluid ounces, a half-gallon is 64 fluid ounces, and a gallon is 128 fluid ounces. So for 12 adults at 8 fluid ounces each you’d want about 96 fluid ounces—roughly three quarts, or just under a gallon. Buying a mix of quarts and pints gives flexibility for samples and leftovers.
Eggnog is perishable—treat it like milk. Keep cartons refrigerated at 40°F or below and consume within the printed use-by date. Once opened, most store-bought eggnog should be used within 5 to 7 days for best taste. If you buy large quantities, store unopened cartons in the coldest section of the fridge and chill for several hours before serving.
You can freeze eggnog, but texture can change due to cream and egg separation. If you plan to freeze, pour portions into airtight containers and thaw slowly in the refrigerator. After thawing, whisk or blend for a few seconds to recombine ingredients. Frozen eggnog works best for cooking or blended cocktails rather than sipping neat.
Store-bought eggnog is a great base—treat it like a canvas. Add a sprinkle of freshly grated nutmeg or cinnamon just before serving to elevate the aroma. For a richer mouthfeel, stir in an ounce of heavy cream per cup or float a dollop of whipped cream on top. Want a grown-up twist? Add a barspoon of spiced rum or a splash of bourbon and garnish with toasted nutmeg.
Try stirring in a teaspoon of vanilla extract, a drizzle of maple syrup for depth, or a pinch of sea salt to balance sweetness. Garnish with cinnamon sticks, grated chocolate, or crushed ginger snaps for texture. These small touches transform a simple carton into a memorable holiday drink.
For collectors and true connoisseurs, limited-edition eggnogs show up at upscale grocers, local creameries, and online specialty retailers. Whole Foods and certain regional supermarkets carry seasonal collaborations and small-batch items. If you want the rare stuff, build a relationship with local dairy suppliers or check specialty food forums and social media for alerts when a new batch drops.
Limited runs often sell out quickly, so shop early in the season—late October through early December—to secure the best selections. For truly rare bottles, signing up for store newsletters or joining loyalty programs gives you a jump on restocks and exclusive preorder options.
Compare prices between national chains like Walmart and Kroger and specialty markets like Whole Foods to balance cost and quality. Check unit price per fluid ounce to spot true bargains, and don’t be afraid to blend two cartons for a customized flavor—mixing a richer brand with a lighter one can yield an ideal texture without extra cost. Above all, experiment and have fun: eggnog should be festive, not fussy.
Whether you’re buying quarts from Trader Joe’s for cozy nights, grabbing a half-gallon at Costco for a big party, or hunting a small-batch bottle at your local creamery, there’s an eggnog out there to match every taste and budget. Cheers to finding your favorite!
Conclusion: store-bought eggnog gives you convenience without sacrificing holiday joy. With a little knowledge about brands, stores, and how to serve or spike that carton, you’ll make any gathering taste like tradition.
