All categories
Business & Offices
Electronics & Media
Fashion & Accessories
Groceries & Essentials
Health & Personal Care
Home & Living
Kids & Family
Sports & Outdoors
Search in ZoneOffer
Loading...
Think of a costume as a cake: the outfit is the sponge, and the accessories are the frosting, sprinkles, and candle—without them, it still works, but it won’t wow anyone. Costume accessories transform a concept into a character, whether you’re aiming for spooky, glamorous, retro, or downright silly. A wig, mask, or prop can push a look from “nice attempt” to “instantly recognizable,” and they’re also the easiest place to save or splurge smartly.
Not all shops are created equal when it comes to accessories. Some excel at quick, affordable pieces for one-night use, while others focus on high-quality, long-lasting props and couture headpieces. Below, I break down reputable U.S. retailers where you’ll find everything from bargain basics to premium pieces.
Party City is the go-to for last-minute grabs and budget-friendly extras. They stock everything from themed jewelry and eye patches to full wig selections, and they often bundle accessories with complete costume themes. If you need a quick, cohesive set—say a pirate pack with hat, belt, and dagger—Party City usually has you covered.
Spirit Halloween is the seasonal giant; if your costume needs licensed props or officially branded accessories (think movie-grade masks or character backpacks), Spirit is a safe bet. Their masks and animatronic props are often show-stoppers, and they carry both kid and adult sizes, making it easier to match scale and realism.
For those who want more authenticity and a wider selection, HalloweenCostumes.com is a great middle ground between budget and boutique. You’ll find specialty items like period hats, theatrical makeup kits, and high-quality capes. Their selection tends to favor thematic depth, so you can assemble a more thoughtful, layered costume.
Amazon is the wildcard: millions of options, varying quality, and fast delivery for Prime members. If you know exactly what you want—say, a 24-inch faux fur collar or a resin prop sword—you can often find it on Amazon for competitive prices. The trick is to read reviews closely and compare photos so you don’t end up with something flimsy.
If uniqueness matters, Etsy shines. Artisans sell handmade masks, vintage brooches, custom headpieces, and leather belts that can help create a truly original look. Turnaround time may be longer, but the craftsmanship and ability to request custom sizing or color make Etsy ideal for cosplay and special events.
Claire’s remains a classic for lightweight costume jewelry, hair clips, glittery headbands, and temporary tattoos. It’s perfect for kids’ costumes and for adults who want playful accents without breaking the bank. Their small, colorful items can be layered to create big visual impact at low cost.
Target’s seasonal selection tends to mirror mainstream trends and seasonal themes. You’ll find simple masks, themed makeup kits, costume hats, and kid-friendly props. Target strikes a balance: better quality than discount dollar-store finds, but often more affordable than specialty boutiques.
Walmart offers a broad selection at low prices, including full costumes and accessory components like gloves, belts, and masks. If you’re putting together a group costume and need multiple similar accessories on a budget, Walmart is a pragmatic choice with many pickup and ship-to-store options.
When you want to customize or craft accessories, Michaels is a hidden gem. They stock feathers, foam, adhesives, paints, and pre-made embellishments that let you upgrade a basic piece into something bespoke. If half your plan is DIY, this is the shop to visit for supplies and inspiration.
Here’s a shortlist of accessory categories that consistently elevate costumes. Think of these as your basic toolkit; mix and match to suit the vibe of your look.
A wig can change everything. From short bobs to 24-inch flowing locks, wigs alter silhouette and immediately read as a different persona. Look for wigs with a breathable cap and heat-resistant fibers if you plan to style them with curling irons. For kids, choose lighter, shorter options that won’t overwhelm their smaller frames.
Masks deliver instant mystery. Silicone or latex prosthetics add realism for horror or fantasy looks, while half-masks and masquerade styles offer intrigue without covering your entire face. If you’re new to prosthetics, start with a small piece like a brow ridge or nose to test glue and removal methods.
Hats anchor many classic looks—from witch hats and pirate tricorns to crowns and fascinators. Pay attention to scale: a 10-inch wide brim reads differently than a subtle 3-inch fascinator. Use hat sizing or adjustable bands to secure larger pieces comfortably for hours.
A prop tells the story your costume can’t. Whether it’s a wand, a vintage-style handbag, or a foam sword, props give your hands something to do and help complete the narrative. If you plan to carry a prop in crowds, opt for lightweight foam or plastic safer than heavy wood or metal.
Jewelry and belts are the finishing touches. Layered necklaces, a character-specific brooch, or a wide belt can change the tone from casual to cinematic. Costume jewelry doesn’t have to be delicate—bold, oversized pieces often photograph best and hold up better during parties.
Choosing accessories is less about brand and more about proportion and comfort. A prop that’s too large will look clumsy; a wig that’s too tight will ruin your night. Here are simple rules that I use when shopping:
- Fit: Measure head circumference or waist before buying hats or belts. Most adult hats fit between 22 and 24 inches in circumference; check sizing guides when available.
- Scale: Compare accessory size to your body. A 6-inch feathered fascinator might disappear on a tall person but pop on someone shorter.
- Material: Pick materials suited to the event. Foam, lightweight plastic, and acrylic are good for crowded venues; leather and metal pieces suit photoshoots and outdoor events where durability matters.
Want an impressive look without the sticker shock? Try thrift stores for vintage belts and brooches, or mix high and low: splurge on a standout wig and pair it with budget jewelry. Seasonal sales—think late October or off-season clearance—are prime time to buy for next year. Signing up for store newsletters can score you a first-time discount or free shipping code.
Buying a cheap accessory and customizing it can produce professional results. Add trim or rhinestones with a hot-glue gun, distress belts with sandpaper for a weathered look, or layer tulle to bulk up a cheap cape. Michaels and craft stores sell embellishments by the yard, so you can upgrade a single store-bought item without breaking the bank.
Accessories can be fun, but safety is key. Avoid props with sharp edges, ensure masks have adequate ventilation, and use skin-safe adhesives for prosthetics. If you’ll be in crowded spaces or on rides, keep props soft and flexible. Also, check local venue rules—many events prohibit realistic weapons or oversized items.
Good storage extends the life of your pieces. Wigs do best on a wig stand, masks can be padded with tissue paper and stored flat, and jewelry should be separated to avoid tangles. For seasonal items, place everything in breathable containers and keep them in a cool, dry place to avoid warping or discoloration.
Want to stay eco-friendly? Renting is a smart route for high-end or one-time looks—costume rental shops offer professionally made pieces without the waste. Buying secondhand or choosing high-quality pieces that can be reused year after year also reduces waste. Many stores now sell sustainably made accessories—look for natural fibers, recycled materials, or pieces from small artisans on platforms like Etsy.
Before leaving, run a quick checklist: secure pins, test adhesive on a small patch of skin, pack spare batteries if your accessory lights up, and bring a small repair kit (safety pins, needle and thread, super glue). With a few quick fixes at hand, most accessory mishaps are easy to solve on the fly.
The best costume often comes from combining resources: buy a statement wig on Etsy, grab props from Spirit Halloween, and finish with jewelry from Claire’s or Target. Mixing stores lets you balance uniqueness, quality, and price. Think of your shopping trip like cooking: pick a premium protein, add affordable sides, and season with unique condiments.
Lighting and posture make accessories pop. For photos, tilt hats slightly to add attitude, angle props for dynamic framing, and use layered jewelry to catch light. At a party, let your accessory be your conversation starter—people love asking about distinctive pieces like handmade masks or elaborate headpieces.
Costume accessories are the little extras that make a big impression. Whether you’re shopping at Party City for last-minute needs, browsing Etsy for one-of-a-kind pieces, or combining finds from Target and Spirit Halloween, the right accessories help tell your character’s story. With thoughtful choices—considering fit, scale, material, and safety—you can build a memorable look without overspending. So experiment, have fun, and let accessories do the heavy lifting for your next costume adventure.
